The council proposes closing Melcombe Primary in August 2027 and moving St Paul's CE Primary onto its Fulham Palace Road site. Responses close on 17 December.

Hammersmith and Fulham Council is proposing to merge two primary schools near Hammersmith Broadway: Melcombe Primary School on Fulham Palace Road and St Paul’s CE Primary School on Worlidge Street.

Under the plan, Melcombe would close on 31 August 2027. St Paul’s would move onto the Melcombe site from 1 September 2027 and carry on as the merged school. It would remain a Church of England voluntary aided school.

No decision has been made. The consultation opened on 5 November and runs until 11.59pm on Thursday 17 December.

Overview

  • What: Melcombe closes and St Paul’s CE relocates to the Melcombe site, making one school.
  • When: 31 August 2027, if approved.
  • Melcombe pupils would join St Paul’s and stay in the same building.
  • St Paul’s pupils would move about half a mile, from Worlidge Street to Fulham Palace Road.
  • Have your say by: 11.59pm on 17 December 2026.

Why the council wants to merge them

Both schools take one class of 30 a year, so each has room for 210 children. Between them they have 207 pupils for 420 places. The council’s initial consultation report gives the figures below, from the schools’ own data on 2 November 2026:

Year group Melcombe St Paul’s
Reception 9 11
Year 1 16 17
Year 2 14 8
Year 3 13 9
Year 4 19 11
Year 5 24 22
Year 6 18 16
Total 113 94

That leaves 46% of Melcombe’s places empty and 55% of St Paul’s. The current Year 6 pupils in both schools would leave in July 2027, before any merger.

The two schools sit in different planning areas. Melcombe’s area, South 2, is forecast to have 710 empty places by 2031/32, or 34% of capacity. St Paul’s area, South 1, is forecast to reach 455 empty places, or 17%, by 2030/31 if nothing changes.

The report gives Melcombe a forecast deficit of £15,220 and St Paul’s a forecast surplus of £407,418.

It is the second named proposal under the council’s review of primary school places. The council is also consulting on closing Flora Gardens Primary School in Brook Green. It says the two proposals do not depend on each other.

Why St Paul’s would move, and not Melcombe

The council prefers the Melcombe site. It says the site could hold the merged school and its larger year groups in the first few years in one place. It also says the site gives more room for special educational needs, shared facilities and outdoor learning.

St Paul’s would be the continuing school because it keeps its legal identity. The report says that avoids the legal and governance work of closing both schools and opening a new one.

The council looked at six other options and did not prefer any of them. They include:

  • keeping both schools open as they are
  • cutting each school’s intake but keeping both
  • running one school permanently across both sites
  • closing both and opening a new school
  • closing St Paul’s and keeping Melcombe

The council has not decided what happens to the Worlidge Street site. It says any proposal will set out how the site, and any money from it, would be dealt with.

The Church of England question

Melcombe is a community school with no religious character. The report says the council “recognises that Melcombe is a community school, and that families may have chosen secular provision”.

The consultation asks directly whether keeping St Paul’s Church of England status is acceptable. It also asks about admissions, religious education, collective worship and access for families of all faiths and none. The council says the answers could lead it to drop the proposal or change it.

The decision to move rests with the St Paul’s governing body, which would make its own formal decision. The report says the council and the governing body have been working together on the plan.

The two nursery schools

Melcombe is part of the Thames Federation with two nursery schools, James Lee and Bayonne. Under the plan, both nurseries would stay community schools with their own identity. They would enter a formal partnership with St Paul’s, led by an executive headteacher, and would not take on a religious character.

Parents’ campaign

A group of parents at St Paul’s has written to Fulham Wire opposing the move. They are a parent group, not the school or its governors. They ask whether keeping both schools at Worlidge Street was assessed, and raise questions about capacity, cost, the building’s heritage and how pupils with special educational needs would be affected.

The council’s report does not list a move to Worlidge Street among the options it assessed.

What happens next

  • 5 November to 17 December 2026: first consultation
  • 11 to 22 January 2027: the council decides whether to publish a formal proposal to close Melcombe, and the St Paul’s governors decide whether to relocate
  • 25 January to 22 February 2027: four weeks for further comments, if a proposal is published
  • 15 March 2027: the council’s final decision, followed by the governors’ formal decision
  • 31 August 2027: Melcombe would close

What it means for you

If your child is at either school, they would not need to apply for a place at the merged school. Parents applying for Reception in September 2027 should name their preferred schools in the usual way. The council says it will contact families directly if the plan goes ahead.

You can respond on the council’s consultation page, by email to SchoolOrganisation@lbhf.gov.uk, or by post to Education Assets, The Civic Campus, 1 Unity Square, London W6 9JU. The deadline is 11.59pm on 17 December.

Sources